
The sportfishing world has kept a sharp eye on the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic’s offshore scene this fall, and not because of the giant bluefin tuna marauding schools of bunker off New Jersey. For over a month, recreational fishermen from New York to Maryland have enjoyed a stellar swordfish bite in the canyons, and many have brought back 500-pound-plus broadbills to their resepctive ports. Last Wednesday, November 11, a crew out of Ocean City, MD, returned from Poorman’s Canyon with a 558-pound sword that will likely earn the state record title. However, a week before that outstanding catch, a group of fishermen from Ocean City, NJ, landed a trophy of their own. On November 4, Eric McDowell, Dan Pettit, Jake Bowles, and Jason Olsen reeled in a 622-pound swordfish off New Jersey and loaded it onto McDowell’s 37-foot Valhalla, Premium Time.
According to Pettit, the four-man squad boarded Premium Time at 4 a.m. and promptly began the 85-mile steam from Great Egg Harbor Inlet to Toms Canyon. It would be more than 16 hours before they returned to the dock at Ocean City Yacht Club.
“We got to Toms around 7:30 a.m.,” Pettit said in an interview. Almost immediately after deploying baits, they were into fish.
“Unfortunately we pulled the hook on the first fish that took our bait,” said Pettit. “Not long after losing that one, we dropped another.”
It was a rough start to an already long morning, prompting a move to the other side of the canyon. “After 10 minutes, we had another fish take the bait—a rigged squid—at 1,300 feet on our first drop,” Pettit added. Jason Olsen jumped on the rod and, unbeknownst to him at the time, would remain there for the next 5 hours.
“It was around 11:15 a.m. when we hooked up,” Pettit recalled. “But we didn’t get eyes on the fish until it finally jumped almost 2 hours into the fight.”
None of the men realized the true size of the fish until it surfaced once again, this time just 25 to 30 feet behind the boat.
“I couldn’t believe how long it was,” Pettit continued. “It came clear out of the water, so we got a good look at it. I’ve caught one swordfish over 500 pounds and a couple over 400; the 500-pounder was 99 inches,” he noted. “This fish completely dwarfed the rest of them. I thought it had to be 600 pounds.”
Finally, at 4:30 p.m., Olsen—who had fought the giant from start to finish on a MerMade Custom rod paired with a Lindgren-Pitman reel—was able to bring the fish boatside. A harpoon and two gaff shots sealed the deal, allowing the crew to tail-rope the broadbill and hoist it over the gunwale.
“Those things just do not give up,” Pettit laughed. “We had 40 to 45 pounds of drag on that fish for the entire fight, and still, we needed over 5 hours to land it.”

With the swordfish safely aboard Premium Time, McDowell pointed the bow toward Great Egg Harbor Inlet. At around 8:30 p.m., they hung the fish from a certified scale at Ocean City Yacht Club. It registered 622.5 pounds—92 pounds heavier than the previous New Jersey swordfish record, caught in Wilmington Canyon by Edmund Levitt in 1964.

“Our fish measured 119 inches—just under 10 feet—from the tip of the lower jaw to the tail fork,” said Pettit. From end to end, including the bill, the fish measured roughly 14 feet long.
McDowell, Pettit, Olsen, and Bowles are submitting an application for the catch to New Jersey’s State Record Fish Program. If certified by the NJDEP Division of Fish & Wildlife, their names will be etched in the record books.
Whether their record will last another 62 years, as Levitt’s did, is anyone’s guess.
» View additional snapshots and videos posted to Valhalla Boatworks’ Instagram page below.
View this post on Instagram
View this post on Instagram
View this post on Instagram
READ MORE



