Long Island and NYC Fishing Report- November 19, 2026

Striped bass continue to blitz across the western South Shore where giant bluefin are making appearances, blackfish are chewing on shallow and deep structure, and squid remain abundant in the Sound.

Long Island and NYC Fishing Report

Mark at Cow Harbor Bait and Tackle (@cowharbortackle) in Northport reports: “The Sound is fishing well. There are a ton of birds working over bass and squid! As for blackfish, the bite is solid, with both shallow grounds and deeper haunts producing good action.”

Captain Adrian Moeller of Rockfish Charters (@rockfishcharters) reports: “This week brought some of the best bass fishing of the year. Huge topwater feeds of bass smashing bunker, with 100-inch-plus bluefin tuna right behind them, tossing 30-pound bass around as if they were bunker. It was such an amazing sight, all within view of the Manhattan skyline! The weather has also been way warmer than normal for mid-November, so it really doesn’t get much better than this. We’re fully booked for 2026, but the 2027 calendar is available on our website: rockfishcharters.com.”

Big bass have been pounding bunker on the surface this week, bringing some of the best blitz action of the year to Rockfish Charters. (IG @rockfishcharters)

The Angler Fleet (@anglerfleet) out of Port Washington reports: “Water temperatures are dropping, and the blackfish are chewing. The squid bite is still going strong, and bass are around, although not consistently or in the numbers we’d like to see.”

Squid fishing has been great throughout Long Island Sound lately and the Angler Fleet is picking away at them to the west. (IG @anglerfleet)

Luke Milano (@luke_milano__) reports: “Over the past week, Jamaica Bay has seen consistent schoolie striped bass action, with the fish seemingly arriving a little later than in years past. These fish have been keyed in on smaller presentations, with 3- to 5-inch paddle tails producing well. Along the oceanfront, the bite has been more hit or miss, with much of the action revolving around schools of bunker. Most of the fish I’ve seen caught from the surf have come on bucktails worked through the troughs along the beach. The bigger bass have generally been feeding farther off the beach, with large topwater plugs like The Freak, metal lips, and heavy swim shads producing most of the bites. I’ve also found the outgoing tide to be more productive over the past week.”

Matt Malone (@mattyhooksets) reports: “It seems like every week this fall run is picking up steam! Bunker everywhere, and where you find the bunker, you find the fish. East or west, it doesn’t matter. Live bunker, white shads, you name it—they’ll hit it. Work the bunker schools on the outside, a little deeper, to keep the dogfish away and get on some good striped bass. Go make the reports for yourself and get out there and fish!”

Matt Malone is keeping dogfish off his hooks long enough for the stripers to find his bait by fishing outside of the bunker schools rather than right beneath them. (IG @mattyhooksets)

Colin McElroy (@colintmcelroy) reports: “Sunrise and sunset have been the ticket most days, with peanuts and cupcakes tight to the beach. There’s been a nice mix of diaper stripers to 20-pound fish. It’s been a tricky bite when the feeding-frenzy madness isn’t happening. Moving around and searching for birds has paid off for those willing to drive around and find the feeds. Hopefully, we’ll see some consistency over the coming week as fall gets fully underway.”

Colin McElroy has covered a lot of ground on the western South Shore to stay on fish when they’re not actively blitzing on peanut and cupcake bunker. (IG @colintmcelroy)

Bill Falco at Chasing Tails Bait and Tackle (@chasingtailsbait) in Oakdale reports: “Fish have been hanging out west of us, and we’re seeing some insane blitz action. They’re loving Super Strike poppers, especially the smaller ones while they’re keyed in on smaller baits. NLBNs in 5- and 8-inch sizes have been getting smoked, and glide baits are being absolutely inhaled. Surf reports are seeing plenty of schoolies to low-slot fish ripping around. Diamond jigs, sand eel soft plastics, and small paddle tails will get it done. Don’t forget to add a teaser. Only one, though! Don’t be that guy. Tog action has been great all along the South Shore and North Shore. They’re still crunching crabs and stealing plenty of rigs. There are big sea bass all over the wrecks and reefs outside, too. There’s plenty of action offshore as well, with big tuna out there challenging any gear you can toss at them! It’s the perfect time to chase some crazy fish before they’re gone.”

Capt. Pete Douma (@doum_flies) of Windward Outfitters out of Montauk reports: “It’s getting toward the end of the bite here, but it never really felt like it got started. The weather has been a bit of an issue, but when we can get out, the fishing has been okay. The albies stuck around through the end of last week, and there are still some bass around. Sand eels and mackerel seem to be the main baits, with sand eels in close and mackerel farther offshore. In close, I’ve been doing well with medium-sized Deceivers on sinking lines, as well as Clousers. Small bucktails and soft plastics in the wash are also producing. For the bigger bait offshore, it’s big flies on sinking lines and swimming lures like Red Fins. The fish are popping on bait, but keeping your fly or lure about a foot below the surface has seemed to outproduce everything else, including jigging. It was an interesting fall here in Montauk, and the fishing could continue producing a little past Thanksgiving, but we’re definitely getting close to the end.”

The fall run is winding down in Montauk, where sand eels and mackerel are fueling the final leg of the striper migration for Captain Pete Douma’s charters. (IG @doum_flies)

Long Island & NYC Fishing Forecast

It’s definitely been a late fall run. We started the fall with sporadic, inconsistent action. The North Shore had its moments early on, but once the autumn winds kicked in, the large body of fish in the eastern Sound peeled off fairly quickly. That said, the deeper western Sound bays and channels near the city are heating up. I believe these are Hudson fish fueling up before wintering over in the East River. They’re feeding on bunker, sand eels, and butters!

On the South Shore, the bass bite is on fire for the boat guys. Fish are mashing bunker, butters, sand eels, and weakfish. Right now it seems like if you have moving water and bait, you’ll find fish. The bass range from slot-sized fish to 45-pounders! On one cast, you might find a giant bass, and on the next, you could be reeling in a slot fish.

The Surface Freak is putting on a clinic around the bunker schools, especially when the bass are actively feeding up top.

Surf fishing has been tough, with a mix of north winds pushing bait schools out of casting range. If you can handle the wait, you’ll get your shot at the right fish. The bass seem to move in and out of casting distance quickly.

As for tog, there are plenty of fish in shallow water, but the larger ones seem to be setting up on deeper structure. As the water continues to cool, we’re going to see more favorable fishing on deeper reefs and wrecks.

Jack is a local Long Islander whose been fishing the western sound for 20 years! Jack has experience surfcasting, boating, and fly fishing both the eastern and western portions of Long Island. 

Leave a Reply

Local Businesses & Captains

Share to...