Montauk Rocks Review

I’d arrived at Montauk in the late afternoon, having left straight from my last class of the week at Villanova. It was mid-September, a bit before prime time, and the fall crowds hadn’t quite materialized yet. Unfortunately, neither had the fall blitzes.  At Paulie’s Tackle, the report was that the fish were holding way off the beach, so I guess I shouldn’t have been surprised when I followed the path down to Turtle Cove and found one of the Montauk surfcasting scene’s most colorful characters, Paul Melnyk, stuffing a live eel into a model rocket he planned to launch toward the horizon.

Paul Melnyk prepares to send an eel where no eel has gone before.

Filming the whole ordeal, was Rich Siberry, who I later met and spoke with outside Paulie’s. Rich, it turned out, had just started filming for a documentary on the fishing and the fishermen at the easternmost end of Long Island. The film was to be called Montauk Rocks.

After hundreds of hours of filming, interviewing, editing and fundraising, Siberry’s project is complete. Having just watched the film, I can say it’s a true fulfillment of the vision Rich described to me on the stoop of Paulie’s half a decade ago. Rich captures the fun, excitement and overall weirdness of the surfcasting scene at Montauk. And I was happy to see the space-bound eel footage included.

To pick up your own copy of Montauk Rocks, click HERE.

Jimmy Fee is the Editor of On The Water and a lifelong surfcaster. He grew up fishing the bridges and beaches of Southern New Jersey before moving to Cape Cod in his early 20s. He's pursued striped bass from North Carolina to Massachusetts. He began with On The Water in 2008, and since then has covered a variety of Northeast fisheries from small pond panfish to bluewater billfish in the through writing, video, and podcasting.

Leave a Reply

Share to...