Two Best Friends Are Building an Offshore Fishing Membership With No Boat Ownership — No Captains Required
Bluewater Syndicate gives experienced anglers access to a Grady-White and Pursuit fleet across multiple bluewater destinations — and its founders are giving back to National Kidney Registry for a deeply personal reason.
Paul Borowiec and his best friend Shenton have logged two decades of offshore fishing together — sharking on a 26-foot Cobia, running double overnighters 100 miles out on a 32-foot center console, hauling in a state-record albacore tuna that still stands in Connecticut. This spring, that friendship turned into a business. Since early May, the two have been building Bluewater Syndicate, a membership that hands experienced anglers the keys to a fully rigged offshore fleet — no boat payments, no slip fees, no captain calling the shots — in four of the Atlantic and Caribbean’s best bluewater fishing grounds.
Twenty Years in the Making
Paul and Shenton met the way a lot of good fishing partnerships start — dragged to the same work party by their wives, talking boats and fishing within minutes. What began as daydreaming about a boat turned into an actual boat: first a 26-foot Cobia they used for shark fishing, then a 32-foot Cape Horn center console they ran hard for years. “We were addicted, relentless, and very successful with our efforts,” the pair write on the Bluewater Syndicate website. “She wasn’t very comfortable, but she was fast, fishy, and very bloody.” One trip still defines the era for both of them: a double overnighter 110 miles out in over 3,000 feet of water that produced a mako shark, a swordfish, yellowfin tuna, mahi-mahi, and a Connecticut state-record albacore tuna that stands to this day.
Then, as it does for most offshore guys, life took over. Careers. Kids. The center console got sold. The fishing didn’t stop, but it slowed to occasional trips instead of a lifestyle — until this year, with the kids older and the itch back, Paul and Shenton started talking about how to get back to full-time offshore fishing without starting from zero.
Paul & Shenton — Two anglers, one program — built exactly the way we wanted to fish.
Why a Membership Instead of Another Boat
For anglers who’ve already put in their time offshore, Paul says the math on ownership stops making sense fast. A boat capable of running to the canyons is expensive to buy, expensive to maintain, and in the Northeast, useless for roughly half the year. “New England winters suck,” as the founders put it — six months of watching the calendar until blue water and canyon season come back around.
The other frustration was more personal: chartering. Paul and Shenton are the kind of anglers who want to run their own spread, pick their own spots, and make their own calls — not hand the boat over to a captain. “Once you’re addicted with it… they don’t want a captain.”
Bluewater Syndicate is built to solve both problems: a membership model that puts members in full control of a fully rigged boat, in destinations with a fishable season, year-round.
What Members Actually Get
Membership is capped at 150 anglers, spread across a fleet of Grady-White and Pursuit Express boats rigged with Shimano tackle, Tiagras, spreader bars and other terminal tackle necessary for offshore trips — ready to fish the moment a member steps aboard. There’s no boat prep, no gear to haul, and no captain standing between a member and the fish.
The fleet is currently being assembled in four bluewater destinations with the first operational boat in the Florida Keys:
Florida Keys — the winter home base, covering sailfish, wahoo, mahi-mahi, and blue and white marlin from November through June, with access to the Gulf Stream and the legendary Islamorada Hump.
New London, Connecticut — the flagship Northeast port, with direct access to the Hudson, Atlantis, Block, Hydrographer, and Oceanographer canyons for bigeye, bluefin, yellowfin, and albacore tuna, plus swordfish and mahi-mahi from July through October.
Cayman Islands — will be stationed at Cayman Islands Yacht Club, fishing the Cayman Trench for marlin, wahoo, and mahi-mahi in some of the clearest water in the Caribbean, year-round.
Nassau, Bahamas — positioned over the Tongue of the Ocean, one of the Atlantic’s best-known blue marlin and wahoo corridors.
Booking runs first-come, first-served through a member portal, with the flexibility to fish private trips with up to three guests or join up with other members. Members cover their own airfare, accommodations and fuel — Bluewater Syndicate handles the boat, the tackle, and the logistics once they land.
The Pursuit 335 OS is one of Pursuit’s best-selling express designs — a deep-V hull that handles Cape and canyon chop with confidence, a huge cockpit built for serious fishing, and a surprisingly upscale cabin that sleeps 4–6. With twin Yamaha 300s, it’s a fast, capable offshore boat that blends comfort, fishability, and reliability.
A Third Partner Joins — and Why
While Paul and Shenton were building the business plan, Paul was carrying something heavier. His 17-year-old son, Logan, was born with a single kidney that has always operated at reduced function, and the family has known for years that a transplant would eventually be necessary. In late May, Paul drove to Boston with his brother Luke for three days of testing to determine whether Luke could be a direct kidney donor for Logan.
It was during that trip — long drives and long conversations in Boston — that Paul first told Luke about Bluewater Syndicate. Watching his brother willingly go through donor testing for his son, Paul says, made the decision easy. He asked Luke to come on board as a partner in Bluewater Syndicate.
“I cannot give anything to you for what you’re doing for Logan,” Paul said. “It’s the best gift anybody can give. I’m going to give you [a stake in] this business, just as a thank you.” Luke accepted, and Bluewater Syndicate now has three owners: Paul, his brother Luke, and his best friend Shenton.
The Donation Behind the Company’s Commitment to Donate Life
Just weeks after that trip to Boston, on June 23, Paul’s wife, Eileen, donated one of her kidneys through the National Kidney Registry’s voucher program — a step that guarantees Logan a living-donor match whenever he ultimately needs a transplant, regardless of whether Luke or anyone else is a direct match.
The timing of it all — the business taking shape, Luke’s testing, Eileen’s donation, Luke joining as a partner — wasn’t lost on Paul. “It’s not a coincidence that this is all happening at once,” he said. Because Bluewater Syndicate came together during one of the most consequential stretches of his family’s life, Paul, Luke, and Shenton have committed to donating 5% of the company’s annual profits to donation-related causes, supporting organ donation awareness for other families navigating the same road.
How to Join
Bluewater Syndicate is currently accepting founding members. Interested anglers can find full details, destination breakdowns, and membership information at bluewatersyndicate.com.
FAQ
What is Bluewater Syndicate?
Bluewater Syndicate is a membership-based offshore fishing club that gives anglers access to a fully rigged fleet of Grady-White and Pursuit boats without the cost of ownership. Members run their own trips with no captain required.
Where does Bluewater Syndicate operate?
The first boat is currently available in the Florida Keys. The founders expect to have boats in: New London, Connecticut; the Cayman Islands; and Nassau, Bahamas by June 2027.
Do I need to hire a captain to use the boats?
No. Bluewater Syndicate is built for experienced offshore anglers who want to run their own boat, tackle, and game plan.
How can I become a member?
Membership is capped at 150 anglers and currently open to founding members. Details are available at bluewatersyndicate.com.
Kevin Blinkoff is the Managing Director and Editor In Chief of On The Water. He’s spent more than 20 years covering striped bass, fisheries science, and the management decisions that shape saltwater fishing in the Northeast. When he’s not editing or corralling the OTW editorial team, he’s usually chasing stripers from a kayak somewhere along the coast.